Score: 2.25/5, Not For Me, But Not Atrocious
Metalcore · Released November 20th, 2026 · Roadrunner Records
I’ve been a fan of Trivium since 8th grade, my first taste being their magnum opus: Shogun. Since the day I first heard them in my friend’s mom’s car, I was hooked and made it a point to go back to their earlier records, and would later wait (sometimes impatiently) for every new release after. I distinctly remember having a countdown with my best friend for the release of In Waves when we were in high school, and thankfully we weren’t disappointed. That record would go on to be the anthem of my cross-country season, Winter/Spring track season, and then the Summer after. I was all in! From there, the band would enter their “awkward” period with the releases of Vengeance Falls and Silence in the Snow. Both records leaned more Hard Rock/radio-ready and weren’t what I wanted from the band. Following these, the awkwardness continued a little with The Sin and the Sentence. The record was a return to form for the band, leaning back into their Metalcore/Thrash roots, with the awkwardness stemming from finding a groove with their new drummer (at the time), Alex Bent. That same awkwardness would later subside with What the Dead Men Say and In the Court of the Dragon (and even the Struck Dead EP released last year), with Alex Bent hitting his stride and delivering some of the best drumming the band has seen/written. Now in 2026, the band is back to having a new drummer in Alex Rüdinger and is yet again facing that awkward transition period that comes with such a shake-up. Crown in the Grave suffers more than The Sin and the Sentence because of this, and is quite possibly my least favorite record from them in 11 years.
Crown in the Grave feels like it was intended to be more ambitious than it actually was. The band’s focus on delivering this as more of an art piece with the album art, themes, and video for “The Terror,” signals the ambition and intent, but doesn’t make up for the overall writing of the record. I always appreciate when Matt embraces his Japanese culture and infuses it into the band’s music, but it mostly falls flat this time. The record feels extremely safe in much of the writing, the drumming, and Matt’s vocals. I often felt like Matt was holding himself back with his newer vocal style that he’s started to adopt. I get that this is him finding the balance between protecting his voice and delivering Metal vocals, but it wasn’t working for me here. The majority of the tracks are weighed down by this element. As for the drumming… I have to chalk it up to the transition period of a new drummer, as I mentioned earlier, because nothing else makes sense to me. You don’t snag a drummer like Alex Rüdinger with the expectation that he’s going to play it safe and deliver relatively simple/stripped back grooves you’d expect on a Hard Rock record. I think the band needs to settle in and find that stride on the next couple of releases as they did with Alex Bent, as long as Rüdinger stays with the band.
I really only have three songs to call out for this record, and one of them is the instrumental opener (Jorōgumo)… Jorōgumo is a great Trivium album opener that fits the overall theme and has an ancient-Japan war-anthem sound. “The Terror” is another standout amongst the less-than-stellar tracks. The track is fast and closer to that classic Trivium sound. Matt’s vocals shine brighter on this track compared to the title track and “Dead Inside of Me” as you work your way from top to bottom of the album. The song is also a better showcase of Rudi’s drumming, but still feels far too safe. “Serpent in the Flame” is the last track I’d mention by name, as it’s the most Trivium-sounding on the album and Rudi opens up a bit more on the kit. The song also ends on the same Japanese motif that started the record, bringing everything full circle. Beyond these three, there aren’t many other moments or tracks for me to call out, and most of my overall sentiments I’ve mentioned already apply to the other tracks. Most of the riffs are forgettable, the drums are safe, Matt’s vocals sound neutered, and there are a few times when a section in a song seems like it’s going to continue or go somewhere exciting, only to be cut at the knees (see the solo and solo outro of “Dead Inside of Me”).
Crown in the Grave can be summed up as a combination of late 80s Metal meets Metalcore in the most uninteresting way, wrapped up in countless layers of bubble wrap and cardboard to make it safe. It’s not going to blow you away, and will likely become a footnote in the band’s history. I put this album a notch above Silence in the Snow and Vengeance Falls, but that’s not saying much considering how much I strongly disliked those two records… The biggest disappointment I had as I reviewed Crown in the Grave is that I had to wait 5 years for their new full-length album, only to get what I consider their third worst record. I had high hopes after their Struck Dead EP last year, but now I’m in a state of worry for their future releases after this album. I really hope in a few years that I get to positively review their next release, because this band means so much to me.
Score: 2.25/5
Get every review in your inbox: sign up here.
More reviews
Kenny’s been obsessed with heavy music since age 10. IT pro by day, reviewer by night. More about me and the scoring scale

